Intransigent anti-communism and/or pragmatic diplomacy? Pius XII’s Eastern policy between world war and cold war
Main Article Content
Abstract
![](https://revistas.unav.edu/social-icons/view.png)
In an investigation involving Vatican sources that have recently been opened for research, the paper reassesses the story of the actual or alleged Vatican-Soviet attempts at rapprochement initiated during and after World War II with the aim to explore the considerations that shaped Vatican eastern policy at the end of the war. Ont he basis of a closer examination of the Orlemanski mission in the spring of 1944, the Flynn mission in March 1945, and the negotiations initiated in 1946 through Hungarian Jesuits it argues that despite Moscow’s brief apparent display of willingness to cooperate at the end of the war, the failure of actual attempts at rapprochement was primarily due to the Kremlin’s lack of interest. By contrast, the Vatican was truly open to dialogue, given the right conditions. Consequently, Pius XII’s Eastern policy is to be interpreted through the paradigm not of intransigence but traditional Vatican concordat policy. The term Ostpolitik, however, unless used with some distinguishing qualification, seems inappropriate to Pius xii’s stance on Eastern policy. Despite the similarities with the Vatican Ostpolitik of the 1960s, a close comparison shows up several basic differences.
Keywords
References
Primary sources
Budapest, Állambiztonsági Szolgálatok Történeti Levéltára [Historical Archives of the State Security Services] 3.2.3. Mt-764/4. «Amadeo»
Москва, Архив Внешней Политики Российской Федерации [The Archive of Foreign Policy of the Russian Federation] fond 06.
Citta del Vaticano, Archivio Apostolico Vaticano, Arch. Deleg. Stati Uniti.
Roma, Archivio Storico Diplomatico del Ministero per gli Aff ari Esteri, Affari Politici (1950-1957), Santa Sede, b. 1671.
Citta del Vaticano, Segreteria di Stato, Sezione per i Rapporti con gli Stati, Archivio Storico, Congregazione degli Affari Ecclesiastici Straordinari.
Citta del Vaticano, Segreteria di Stato, Sezione per i Rapporti con gli Stati, Archivio Storico, Spogli.
Secondary sources
Balogh, Margit, Fejérdy, András, Az Orlemanski-akció, avagy egy amerikai pap különös útja a Szovjetunióba, en István Zombori (coord.), Ecclesiae et historiae servus infatigabilis. Tanulmányok Somorjai Ádám 70. születésnapjára. metem, Budapest, 2022, pp. 165-195. http://real.mtak.hu/159360/1/Balogh-FejerdyOrlemanski.pdf
Balogh, Margit, A kalot és a katolikus társadalompolitika 1935-1946, MTA Történettudományi Intézete (Társadalom és művelődéstörténeti tanulmányok 23), Budapest, 1998.
Balogh, Margit, Lehetőségek és zsákutcák. Szentszéki képviseletek Kelet-Közép-Európában 1945 után, en Mihály Zoltán Nagy, István Zombori (coords.), Állam és egyház kapcsolata Kelet-Közép-Európában 1945 és 1989 között. Intézmények és módszerek, metem, Budapest, 2014, pp. 9-32. http://real.mtak.hu/19538/1/Balogh_Margit_Lehetosegek_es_zsakutcak_u_174813.911556.pdf
Barberini, Giovanni (ed.), La politica del dialogo. Le Carte Casaroli sull'Ostpolitik vaticana, Il Mulino (Santa Sede e politica del Novecento 7), Bologna, 2009.
Blet, Pierre, Graham, Robert A., Martini, Angelo, Schneider, Burckhardt (eds.), Actes et documents du Saint Siège relatifs à la seconde guerre mondiale, vol. 5, Le Saint Siège et la guerre mondiale juillet 1941-Octobre 1942, Libreria Editrice Vaticana, Città del Vaticano, 1969 https://www.vatican.va/archive/actes/documents/Volume-5.pdf
Blet, Pierre, Graham, Robert A., Martini, Angelo, Schneider, Burckhardt (eds.), Actes et documents du Saint Siège relatifs à la seconde guerre mondiale, vol. 3b, Le Saint Siège et la situation religieuse en Pologne et dans les pays Baltes 1939-1945, Libreria Editrice Vaticana, Città del Vaticano, 1967. https://www.vatican.va/archive/actes/documents/Volume-3b.pdf
Blet, Pierre, Graham, Robert A., Martini, Angelo, Schneider, Burckhardt (eds.), Actes et documents du Saint Siège relatifs à la seconde guerre mondiale, vol. 11, Le Saint Siège et la Guerre mondiale Janvier 1944-Mai 1945. Libreria Editrice Vaticana, Città del Vaticano, 1981. https://www.vatican.va/archive/actes/documents/Volume-11.pdf
Davis, Donald E., Trani, Eugene P., The Reporter Who Knew Too Much. Harrison Salisbury and the New York Times, Rowman & Littlefield, Lanham, MD, 2012.
Di Giovanni, Francesca, Roselli, Giuseppina (eds.), Inter arma caritas. L'Ufficio Informazioni Vaticano per i prigionieri di Guerra, istituito da Pio xii (1939-1947). I. Inventario, ii. Documenti, Libreria Editrice Vaticana (Collectanea Archivi Vaticani 52), Città del Vaticano, 2004.
Di Nolfo, Ennio, Dear Pope. Vaticano e Stati Uniti. La corrispondenza segreta di Roosevelt e Truman con Papa Pacelli dalle carte di Myron Taylor, IN-EDIT-A, Roma, 2003.
Dickinson, Anna, Domestic and Foreign Policy Considerations and the Origins of Postwar Soviet Church-State Relations, 1941-6. en Dianne Kirby (coord.), Religion and the Cold War, Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, 2003, pp. 23-36. https://doi.org/10.1057/9781403919571_2
Fejérdy, András, Aux origines de la nouvelle Ostpolitik du Saint-Siège. La première tentative de Jean xxiii pour reprendre le contact avec les évêques hongrois en 1959, en Archivum Historiae Pontificiae 46 (2008), pp. 389-411.
Fejérdy, András, Il 1956 come punto di svolta? La rivoluzione ungherese nella politica orientale della Santa Sede, en: András Fejérdy (coord.), La rivoluzione ungherese del 1956 e l'Italia, Rubettino, Soveria Mannelli, 2017, pp. 131-141.
Fejérdy, András, Modus vivendi with Moscow? The 1945 Flynn Mission and the Eastern Policy of Pius xii, en Revue d'Histoire Ecclésiastique, 117 (2022) pp. 711-734. https://doi.org/10.1484/J.RHE.5.132872
Fejérdy, András, Nagy Töhötöm, a kalot és xii. Piusz pápa keleti politikája, (Soon to be published).
Fejérdy, András, Pressed by a Double Loyalty. Hungarian Attendance at the Second Vatican Council, 1959-1965, CEU Press, Budapest-New York, 2016. https://doi.org/10.1515/9789633861431
Hägglöf, Gunnar, Fredens vägar 1945-1950, Norstedt, Stockholm, 1973.
Herzog, Jonathan P., The Spiritual-Industrial Complex. America's Religious Battle against Communism in the Early Cold War, Oxford University Press, New York, 2011.
Hürten, Heinz, Was heißt Vatikanische Ostpolitik? Eine einführende Skizze, en Karl-Joseph Hummel (coord.), Vatikanische Ospotlitik unter Johannes xxiiii. und Paul vi. 1958-1978. F. Schöningh, Paderborn-München-Wien-Zürich, 1999, 1-17.
Ickx, Johan, Keresztes, András, Somorjai, Ádám (eds), Scontrarsi o negoziare? Alternative dei Cattolici nel dopoguerra in Ungheria alla luce di alcuni documenti Vaticani. Ütközni vagy időt nyerni? Katolikus alternatívák 1945 után néhány vatikáni dokumentum fényében, metem, Budapest, 2020. https://mek.oszk.hu/21300/21393/21393.pdf
Ickx, Johan, L'Ostpolitik di Pio xii. Il «modus vivendi» proposto a Mosca 1946-1947. Il caso di padre Alessandro Töhötöm Nagy S. J, en Emilia Hrabovec, Giuliano Brugnotto, Peter Jurčaga (coords.), Chiesa del silenzio e diplomazia pontificia 1945-1965. / Umlčaná cirkev a pápežká diplomacia 1945-1965. Libreria Editrice Vaticana (Atti e documenti 49), Città del Vaticano, 2018, pp. 155-179.
Inboden, William, Religion and American Foreign Policy, 1945-1960. The Soul of Containment, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2008. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511499173
Keresztes, András (ed.): Kerkai Jenő és Nagy Töhötöm levelezése (1939-1969). efo, Százhalombatta, 2019. https://mek.oszk.hu/16900/16975/16975.pdf
Kirby, Dianne (coord.), Religion and the Cold War, Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, 2002. https://doi.org/10.1057/9781403919571
ЛЕВ, Квин, Улица Королевы Вильгельмины. Повесть о странностях времени, АОЗТ «Полиграфист», 1996. https://antpoz.wixsite.com/lev-kvin/ulica1
Мурашко, Галина П., Восточная Европа в документах российских архивов 1944- 1953 гг. Том 1. 1944-1948, Сибир. хронограф, Москва-Новосибирск, 1997. http://docs.historyrussia.org/ru/indexes/values/1081195
Nagy, Töhötöm, Napló 1944-1946, kapcsolódó dokumentumokkal, ed por András Keresztes, efo, Százhalombatta, 2019. https://mek.oszk.hu/16700/16719/16719.pdf
Pastorelli, Pietro, La Santa Sede e l'Europa centro-orientale nella seconda metà del Novecento, Rubbettino, Soveria Mannelli, 2013.
Perkins, E. Ralph, Gleason, S. Everett, Churchill, Rogers P., Reid, John G., Sappington, N. O., Houston, Douglas W., Rison Jones, John, Reynolds, Warren H. (eds.), Foreign Relations of the United States: Diplomatic Papers, 1944, Europe, iv, United States Government Printing Office, Washington, 1966. https://history.state.gov/historicaldocuments/frus1944v04/
Petrás, Éva, Álarcok mögött. Nagy Töhötöm életei, ÁBTL-Kronosz, Budapest-Pécs, 2019.
Plechatnov, Vladimir O., «The Allies are Pressing on you to Break your Will...» Foreign Policy Correspondence Between Stalin and Molotov and other Politburo Members, September 1945-December 1946, en https://www.wilsoncenter.org/sites/default/files/media/documents/publication/ACFB29.PDF
Plokhy, Serhii, Yalta, the Price of peace. Viking, New York, 2010.
Roccucci, Adriano, Stalin e il patriarca. La Chiesa ortodossa e il potere sovietico, Einaudi, Torino, 2011.
Stehle, Hansjakob, Die Ostpolitik des Vatikans 1917-1975, Piper, München-Zürich, 1975.
Trasatti, Sergio, Vatican Kremlin. Les secrets d'un face-à-face, Payot, Paris, 1993.
Волокитина, Татьяна B. (ed.), Власть и церковь в Восточной Европе, 1944-1953.
Документы российских архивов: в 2 т. Т. 1. 1944-1948. РОССПЭН, Москва, 2009. https://inslav.ru/images/stories/pdf/2009_Vlast%27_i_cerkov%27.pdf
Wallace, James C., A Religious War? The Cold War and Religion, en Journal of Cold War Studies 15 (2013), pp. 162-180. https://www.jstor.org/stable/26924388 https://doi.org/10.1162/JCWS_a_00374
Wenger, Antoine, Rome et Moscou 1900-1950, Desclée de Brouwer, Paris, 1987.
Details
Article Details
![Creative Commons License](http://i.creativecommons.org/l/by-nc-nd/4.0/88x31.png)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
RIGHTS TRANSFER
By submitting the article for evaluation and subsequent publication in Anuario de Historia de la Iglesia, the AUTHOR grants exclusive economic and/or exploitation rights: reproduction, distribution, public communication, transformation/translation/creation of derivative works, and commercialisation to the University of Navarra through its Publications Service, for the maximum legal period in force -the author's lifetime and seventy years after his or her death or declaration of death-, in any country, and in any of the current and future publishing modalities, both in print and electronic versions.
In the event that the article is not accepted for publication , this transfer of rights lapses with the communication of the refusal to the AUTHOR.
The AUTHOR affirms that the article is unpublished, that it has not been sent simultaneously to another publication medium and that the rights have not been transferred exclusively previously. He is responsible to the University of Navarra through its Publications Service for the authorship and originality of his work, as well as for all pecuniary charges that may arise for the University of Navarra through its Publications Service, in favor of third parties due to actions, claims or conflicts arising from the breach of obligations by the AUTHOR.